Extended versions?

[AnotherHeartbreak]

I have every CD, DVD, and most cassettes BNL have ever put out, but one CD I don't have is the "Extended Versions" live CD. I haven't heard very great things about it. Is it a good CD?

[IWakeUpStrange]

It's a decent collection of live tracks, but if you regularly buy/collect bootlegs, it's nothing special. You can usually find it pretty cheap, in bargain racks and the like.

:) elise

[Liam]

Don't bother. :)

[AnotherHeartbreak]

Don't bother. :)

Really? How come?

[TheHYPO]

It's a decent collection of live tracks, but if you regularly buy/collect bootlegs, it's nothing special. You can usually find it pretty cheap, in bargain racks and the like.

:) elise


To clarify, it's a decent collection of live tracks collected from the band's online-release concerts (I don't believe it's professionally remixed, but I could be wrong). I believe they were taken mostly (or entirely) from the 2005 holiday tour. I too have heard bad things, but I can't remember what they were. I don't believe they looked hard for the best performances or anything like that, for example. I can't confirm anything though, since I have never heard the CD other than sample clips, but just based on those clips, I've heard better performances of those songs in the BNL bootleg collection.

[Liam]

To clarify, it's a decent collection of live tracks collected from the band's online-release concerts (I don't believe it's professionally remixed, but I could be wrong). I believe they were taken mostly (or entirely) from the 2005 holiday tour. I too have heard bad things, but I can't remember what they were. I don't believe they looked hard for the best performances or anything like that, for example. I can't confirm anything though, since I have never heard the CD other than sample clips, but just based on those clips, I've heard better performances of those songs in the BNL bootleg collection.

AnotherHeartbreak: this is basically why I said "don't bother". It's just nothing special, not worth the money. I have heard far better versions of all the songs on it elsewhere. :)

[Suebee42]

I picked it up cheap somewhere, just to be a completist (and because seeing BNL CDs in the bargain bins makes me sad... I considered it a "rescue" ;) ), but I haven't actually listened to it or loaded the tracks into iTunes.